10
Wood Box Magnolia Makeover
Two thrift store wood boxes cleaned with degreaser, sanded with 80 grit then 220 grit, neutralized with a dusting of sand-tone spray paint. Applied watered-down taupe paint in a perfect neutral brown that dries lighter than it applies. Used painters tape to create linear stripe details along the sides — a recurring Magnolia design element. Applied wax (not diluted) over the tape-protected stripes with a wax brush, then finished with antiquing wax. Added aged brass hinges ($7 for both) for the final detail.
✓ Under $10 each
Magnolia
11
Melamine Tray Aged Brass Finish
$1.25 thrifted tray converted to aged brass using three layered spray paints: metallic brass base, matte black over it, then champagne bronze to finish. This is a forgiving combination — if too much black lands in one area, add more brass or bronze to soften it. Because the spray paints were already on hand, the project cost only $1.25. Now complements open shelving alongside Pottery Barn equivalents that retail for $40–70.
✓ $1.25 (spray on hand)
Pottery Barn
12
Plaster-of-Paris Distressed Vase
Thrift store vase (under $1 at the bins) given the Hearth & Hand distressed pottery look. Mixed plaster of Paris with white acrylic paint and applied two to three coats for complete coverage. Gently sanded with 220 grit to remove any raised texture. Applied watered-down antiquing wax and wiped off excess with a paper towel — gives the same slightly uneven, chalky surface that Hearth & Hand achieves on their distressed pottery line.
✓ Under $2
Hearth & Hand
13
Three-Piece Aged Brass Decor Set
Three thrift store pieces under $10 total, all given the aged brass treatment using Rustoleum Classic Bronze spray paint. The key advantage of this product: it delivers a convincing matte patina in a single can without layering three separate spray paints. After the base coat, add a few targeted dustings of black spray paint in recessed areas for variation — real patina never develops completely evenly. Finish with a matte clear sealer. Suitable for shelf styling, entryway tables, and coffee table vignettes.
✓ $20 total (3 pieces + spray)
Magnolia
14
Glass Fishbowl Vase — Textured Brass Conversion
50¢ glass fishbowl vase converted to a patinated textured metal finish, duplicating a Pottery Barn brass rounded vase. Process: scuff sand the glass, mix grout with acrylic paint (any colour) and apply as a texture coat — this is the step that makes the surface read as metal rather than painted glass. Layer textured black spray, then metallic brass, then sand lightly between layers to reveal depth. Add antiquing wax in recessed areas. Keep referencing the inspiration image and keep tailoring until satisfied. Seal with matte clear coat. Then source hot pink peonies or similar statement florals.
✓ Under $5
vs.
Pottery Barn $50+
Pottery Barn
15
Brass Tray with Painted Glass Insert
Thrifted brass tray whose handles closely matched a McGee & Co. tray — the only difference was theirs was solid brass, not glass-centred. Solution: sand the glass insert with fine grit for adhesion, apply the brass spray paint to the glass in light coats (verify paint compatibility with glass before starting), then layer on champagne bronze acrylic paint with a brush for an overall matte aged finish.
✓ Under $5
McGee & Co.
16
Butcher Block Angled Cutting Board
Thrift store butcher block cut at an angle to match the McGee & Co. version using a borrowed circular saw blade. Sanded through 60, 120, then 220 grit. Finished with antiquing wax (neutral brown tone). Added a hand-cut leather strap for the peg rail mounting detail — a small addition that elevates the piece from functional to decorative.
✓ A few dollars
McGee & Co.
17
Milk Glass Bunny Patinaed Brass Conversion
Existing piece (no new purchase needed) converted to replicate a sold-out patinaed brass bunny container from Magnolia. Layers: metallic gold spray paint base → matte brown acrylic with foam brush → watered-down black paint → flour dusted on while still wet to mattify → champagne gold acrylic for vintage highlights. Each layer is thin; build up gradually. Not an identical match but achieves the same warm aged-metal aesthetic.
✓ Zero additional spend
Magnolia
18
Twisted Trim Planter Aged Stone Finish
Large thrift store planter with floral motifs (not on-trend). Spray painted black first, then applied peel-and-stick twisted trim (from Amazon) using E6000 rather than just the adhesive backing — the peel-and-stick adhesive alone is insufficient for long-term durability. Mixed grout with white acrylic paint in equal parts, applied two coats for full coverage. Distressed with watered-down wax, blending with a paper towel to pull back colour selectively. Added a small concentrated wax bead to the rim for an aged edge effect.
✓ Under $15
Studio McGee
19
Chandelier Floral Taper Candle Holder
Removed decorative floral elements from a thrifted chandelier and combined with a 50¢ thrifted plate base. Drilled a small hole through the plate and widened one of the metal flowers with a drill bit to accept a taper candle. Taped the metal while drilling to contain shards. Screwed the two pieces together. Spray painted metallic brass, then dusted with black spray for patina effect. Recalls Anthropologie candle holders at a fraction of the cost.
✓ Under $3 total
Anthropologie
20
Dough Bowl Citronella Candle
Thrift store dough bowl cleaned with nail polish remover to strip existing acrylic and spray paint, then sanded smooth. Melted candle wax using a double-boiler system. Placed four wicks (secured with kebab sticks and tape) evenly across the bowl surface. Added citronella fragrance oil to the melted wax before pouring. Four wicks ensure even melt-down across the large surface. A functional outdoor piece that also reads as decorative.
✓ Under $10
vs.
Pottery Barn / Anthropologie $35–40
21
Glass Taper Candle Holders Set
Three thrifted glass taper holders for $6 total — not as detailed as a high-end store's $34-per-piece version, but entirely functional and visually similar when grouped together as a vignette. Sometimes the most effective strategy is quantity over modification: three imperfect thrifted pieces styled together read better than one expensive piece alone.
✓ $6 for three
vs.
Retail $34 each
22
Thrifted Garland Wreath — Wedding Florals
Post-wedding season is the best time to find high-quality, matched floral stems at Goodwill. Wedding centerpieces use consistent flower types and typically high-quality faux or dried stems. Using two foam wreath forms (one large, one small to nest inside the other) gives the fullness seen in high-end wreath designs. Spray with UV protectant on all green leaves to prevent them turning blue by end of season — skipping this step consistently results in colour loss.
✓ Under $20
vs.
William Sonoma / Anthropologie $80+
Leave a Comment
Which of the 50 projects are you trying first? Share your thrift finds, results, or questions below.